5 weight loss myths you want to believe – but shouldn’t

Emma & Beth - Nutracheck Nutritionists | 11 May, 2025

Healthy Balance magazine!

Spring edition now live.
Find it in the app – tap 'More'.

Have you ever come across a weight loss “fact” that sounds like the answer to all your struggles? With the rise of social media and countless celebrity-endorsed diets flooding your feed, it’s no wonder that separating fact from fiction can feel like a full-time job.

Even the savviest dieters can fall for common weight loss myths. Why? Because these myths often promise quick fixes, simple rules, or magic “hacks” that feel like shortcuts to results. But here’s the truth — many of these ideas can actually stall your progress rather than help it.

Why weight loss myths are so tempting

Weight loss can feel tough, so it’s only natural to gravitate toward solutions that seem quick, easy, or effortless. Whether it’s a trendy new diet, a viral fitness hack, or a so-called “miracle” food, we all want to believe there’s a simpler way to achieve our goals.

But misinformation spreads fast — especially online — and not everything that sounds good is backed by science. That’s why it’s so important to focus on evidence-based advice that delivers lasting results you can count on.

5 myths you may wish were true — but aren’t

Portion control

1“You can burn belly fat with ab exercises”

Wouldn’t it be great if crunches could melt away belly fat? Unfortunately, most research shows that spot reduction doesn’t work [1]. Studies have found that you can’t target fat loss in specific areas — although you can build muscle, which changes how that area looks. The best way to lose belly fat is to reduce overall body fat with a combination of calorie deficit, strength training, and cardio.


NC advice: Combine consistent workouts with a calorie deficit to target your body as a whole — not just particular areas.

Selective memory

2“Certain foods speed up your metabolism”

The idea that certain foods can magically boost your metabolism and burn fat is tempting — but the science doesn’t really back it up. While green tea and apple cider vinegar have been studied for metabolic effects, the results are modest and unlikely to have a noticeable impact on weight loss [2].

If you enjoy green tea or use apple cider vinegar in recipes, go for it! But instead of chasing quick fixes, focus on what works: building muscle through strength training, staying active, and managing calorie intake. These are far more effective ways to support your metabolism and see long-term progress.


NC advice: Focus on sustainable habits like strength training and balanced meals instead of relying on “quick fix” foods and drinks.

Woman weighing

3“Cutting carbs is the fastest way to lose weight”

It’s true that low-carb diets can lead to quick results on the scale — but here’s the catch: most of that early weight loss is water, not fat [3]. Carbs are stored as glycogen, which binds to water. So when you cut carbs, your body sheds water weight first.

The reality is, long-term weight loss comes down to a calorie deficit — burning more calories than you eat. Whether or not your diet includes carbs, it’s your total calorie intake that matters. Cutting carbs completely isn’t necessary and often isn’t sustainable.


NC advice: Enjoy carbs in moderation as part of a balanced diet. Whole grains, fruits, and vegetables provide energy and support your goals.

Healthy fats

4“Eating ‘clean’ means you don’t need to track calories”

It’s easy to assume that if you're eating healthy, unprocessed foods, you don’t need to worry about how much you’re eating — but that’s not quite true. Nutrient-rich foods like nuts, avocados, and olive oil are packed with good fats and vitamins, but they’re also calorie-dense.

For example, one tablespoon of olive oil has about 123 calories. It’s easy to pour more than you think when cooking. Likewise, a handful of nuts can top 200 calories if you’re not mindful.

The takeaway? These foods are great for your health, but portion control and calorie tracking still matter.


App Tip: Use Nutracheck to quickly and accurately log calorie-dense foods like nuts, seeds, and oils. It’s an easy way to stay on track while enjoying a healthy, balanced diet.

Planning

5“You have to exercise for weight loss”

It’s a common belief that you need to hit the gym hard to lose weight — but in reality, your diet plays a bigger role. Exercise is fantastic for your health and well-being, but it’s easier to create a calorie deficit through food choices. Skipping a 500-calorie snack is simpler than burning 500 calories on a treadmill — which could take over an hour.

That said, don’t skip exercise altogether. It helps maintain muscle mass, supports your metabolism, boosts your mood, and improves sleep. In fact, studies show that combining exercise with a healthy diet leads to better long-term weight maintenance [4].

The bottom line? You don’t need hours of intense workouts, but pairing regular movement with mindful eating is a winning strategy.

NC advice: Choose activities you enjoy — like walking, dancing, or strength training — and pair them with a balanced, calorie-conscious diet for lasting success.

The truth about sustainable weight loss

Real, lasting weight loss isn’t about quick fixes, hacks, or magic solutions. It’s about building habits you can stick to, staying consistent, and being patient with the process.

If you’re unsure about weight loss advice, look for trusted sources like registered dietitians, CDC guidelines, or evidence-based research. And remember — if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.

Nutritionists Emma White (ANutr), MSc Human Nutrition and Beth Furness (ANutr), BSc Nutrition and Health, are passionate about diet and how this impacts overall health. They support evidence-based advice around nutrition and aim to help everyone better understand how different nutrients affect the body and long-term health status.

This site uses cookies to personalise content and ads, provide social media features and analyse our traffic. Find out more about how we use cookies.

Choose which cookies you allow us to use. You can read more about our Cookie Policy in our Privacy Policy.